Fair Lending Risk Didn’t Disappear — It Changed Locations

Alesha Briley is senior regulatory intelligence expert with Ncontracts.

Alesha Briley

In 2022, a bank agreed to pay $13 million to settle redlining allegations and entered a five-year consent order. Last year, the Department of Justice asked the court to end the order two years early, but the judge denied the request, saying the bank needed to meet all the terms of the original consent order.

Fair lending enforcement may seem like it’s easing up. The OCC dropped disparate impact from its exam scope last year, while the FDIC stretched certain consumer compliance examinations for well-rated small banks to five or six years with only a midcycle check-in. The CFPB has also scaled back exam activity across the board.

Yet the consent order case shows that fair lending risk didn’t disappear. It just relocated. Courts, state Attorney General offices, and private plaintiffs may pursue theories that receive less attention under current federal exam priorities.

Where the Risk Went

Fair lending expectations still hold, but they now live in less obvious places than a federal exam schedule.

Private litigation is one of those venues. Both the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA) and the Fair Housing Act (FHA) give individuals the right to sue, and the bar to file is low. An attorney can pull your HMDA data, run it through analytics software, and identify statistical disparity patterns that warrant further scrutiny.

State enforcement works on a parallel track. The Supreme Court’s 2015 ruling in Texas Department of Housing v. Inclusive Communities Project grounded disparate impact liability in the Fair Housing Act’s statutory text, not in HUD’s regulations. That means states with their own disparate impact laws can enforce them through their AG’s office regardless of what federal agencies are doing. New Jersey and Connecticut have already moved in this direction, and more states are likely to follow.

Timing adds another layer. ECOA claims carry a five-year statute of limitations, and FHA claims carry two. A lending decision that clears today’s exam without comment can still get scrutinized years from now by a plaintiff’s attorney, a state AG or a future administration reading the same data differently.

While these risks arise under different legal theories, ranging from redlining and disparate impact to state consumer protection and anti-discrimination laws, each can create fair lending exposure outside of current federal exam priorities.

Takeaway: A clean exam doesn’t mean your program is risk-free. It means nothing surfaced this cycle, and the underlying disparity, if it exists, is still there until you find it yourself.

States Aren’t Waiting on Washington

Where federal agencies have stepped back, state legislatures and regulators are stepping forward. For example, New York’s FAIR Business Practices Act, effective this year, expanded the state’s consumer protection law to cover unfair and abusive conduct, giving its AG broader enforcement reach. 

The proliferation of AI tools in lending has also caught the attention of state AGs. New Jersey codified disparate impact protections for housing and lending under its Law Against Discrimination, with specific guidance on how that liability applies to AI and automated decision-making tools, while Connecticut followed with a memorandum confirming that the state’s anti-discrimination and credit laws apply to AI-driven lending decisions the same way they apply to any other lending decision. States are making it clear that scale doesn’t change the liability. A model that scores thousands of applications a day carries the same disparate impact exposure as a loan officer who reviews one. 

Takeaway: If your program is built solely around federal exam priorities, you may miss emerging state-level expectations. The states you operate in may impose broader or different fair lending and AI-related requirements.

What This Means for Your Program

Your fair lending program works best as a living process, something you’re actively working regardless of federal regulatory priorities. That’s a shift in cadence more than a rebuild.

Track your primary regulator’s specific exam posture rather than assuming the industry-wide pullback applies evenly. Revisit HMDA data on your own schedule instead of waiting for an exam to surface a disparity. Fair lending compliance software built for ongoing monitoring makes that a lot more realistic than doing it manually once a year. And check any state you lend in against its own fair lending and AI rules, since several states have already moved past where the federal regulators currently sit.

The exam might be quieter, but the exposure isn’t. Finding your fair lending disparities now costs a lot less than answering for them in a lawsuit later.

(Views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect policies of the Mortgage Bankers Association, nor do they connote an MBA endorsement of a specific company, product or service. MBA NewsLink welcomes submissions from member firms. Inquiries can be sent to Editor Michael Tucker or Editorial Manager Anneliese Mahoney.)