JLL: Real Estate Transparency Gap Widens in Favor of Leading Global Markets

JLL, Chicago, said while many of the world’s leading commercial real estate markets in North America, Western Europe and Australasia are becoming more transparent, most other countries struggle to maintain the pace of transparency improvement.

The JLL/LaSalle Global Real Estate Transparency Index also found more widespread adoption of green and healthy building certifications.

“The influence of external events including geopolitical conflict, economic volatility and lingering effects of COVID-19 that has permeated the last two years has had widespread effects on the global real estate market,” said Richard Bloxam, CEO of JLL Capital Markets, JLL. “Transparency is the foundation which allows corporate occupiers, as well as investors and lenders to the world’s largest asset class, to operate and make decisions with confidence. While we are encouraged to see increased transparency in many of the world’s leading markets, limited improvements in many other global markets have resulted in one of the slowest rates of progress in the index’s history and highlights growing disparity in transparency around the world.”

Jacques Gordon, Head of Global Strategy and Research for LaSalle Investment Management, said sustainability is the leading driver of transparency improvements in this year’s survey, a continuing trend since 2018.

“Net zero emissions are the current focus for many investors, companies and governments in the most transparent countries around the world, with an increasing number of countries and cities following up on previously announced climate commitments by establishing mandatory energy efficiency and emissions standards for buildings, Gordon said. “The research also found more widespread adoption of green and healthy building certifications, which we expect will continue to accelerate in the years ahead.”

The report said European markets have made the most progress in sustainability through implementation of the EU’s updated Energy Performance of Buildings Directive and other regulations including the European Green Deal.

Paris, New York City and London topped the sustainability sub-index as the world’s leading cities to set the pace in adopting measures to raise or track progress toward sustainability goals. In particular, the report said New York City has been active in implementing clear, long-term building energy standards through measures that include Local Laws 84 and 97, the Construction Codes Revision Bill and mandating the tracking of energy consumption at the building level.

For the first time in the Index’s history, Japan has been included in the list of ‘Highly Transparent’ markets, as it pushes forward net zero carbon goals through higher building standards and transparency around climate risk reporting. Meanwhile, the UAE markets of Abu Dhabi and Dubai are the top global improvers in 2022 benefiting from a concerted government focus on increasing real estate transparency. As a result, Dubai makes its first appearance in the ‘Transparent’ tier.

The report noted during the COVID-19 pandemic, the pace of technological innovation increased to adapt to the drastic changes affecting the way people live and work. Real estate is no different, as technology platforms expanded data availability, enabling an in-depth understanding of buildings and markets. Available data ranges from pricing information for niche sectors to real-time occupancy tracking and digital simulations of cities and buildings.

“Advanced data techniques that can scrape information from listings sites, ‘big data’ platforms and geographic information systems are all enabling investors and occupiers to compile better information,” the report said. “To this end, adoption of real estate technology is growing rapidly, with venture capital funding for real estate technology companies reaching a record high of $18.2 billion in 2021 and nearly 8,000 companies providing real estate technology solutions globally, an increase of over 300% from 10 years ago.”

The report said countries with the highest rates of transparency also have the highest levels of technology adoption, including the UK, U.S., France, Netherlands, Belgium, Ireland, Canada and Germany. Real estate technology adoption is also prevalent in some territories lower down the transparency ranking, including Dubai and China. 

The report also noted investments in alternative property sectors such as lab space, senior living facilities, student housing and data centers continue to grow as diversification becomes increasingly important for investors. Global investment in alternative real estate sectors increased by 69% between 2019 and 2021 and every country in the 2022 survey reported having inventory of historically niche property types, with 65% of countries reporting some institutional investment in alternatives. Data centers represented the broadest global reach. The U.S. leads on data for these alternative sectors, but they are now becoming much easier to track across Europe and in major Asia Pacific markets like Japan and China.

“Historically, reliable market data on alternative properties was often scarce, or non-existent, even in otherwise highly transparent real estate markets,” the report said. “The tremendous global growth in alternative property investment indicates that this will be a critical space to watch in coming years as advanced data technologies create an ideal environment for greater transparency in this space.”